WP Symposium Pro - Extensions Plugin

This demonstration has expired, please purchase a licence or uninstall the WP Symposium Pro Extensions plugin - get a valid licence code here.

A place to discuss Mystery Suspense Fiction. ASMSG Authors in this genre are displayed below forum posts. 

This is a public forum, but only ASMSG members can add or reply to posts.

Back to ASMSG Forums or Mystery Suspense Hub

Reviewers: Be Fair to Writers (1 reply)

2 years ago
professor 2 years ago

When an author presents his newly published book to the reading public, he is invariably taking a risk. He is leaving himself vulnerable to the whims and vagaries of the reviewing cadre. Many writers also write reviews and they generally understand the psychological niceties. But many reviewers are not writers. Nevertheless, for the most part they tend to responsible and fair-minded. Criticism from these, positive or negative, is tolerable even to the most thin-skinned writer.

There is that small coterie of reviewers, however, who believe that their job is to find a weakness in a work and spend the bulk of their review focussed on that. It may well be that such negative reviewing is in some way related to the reviewer’s ego, but I cannot be sure about that. To my mind, however, it is a very poor way to review a whole book.

Having written something in the region of 120 reviews, I have unconsciously developed an approach to reviewing which might well be something reviewers should consider. Some books, of course, are so badly written, so poorly structured, so lacking in plot or coherence, that the only approach is simply not to review them. But if a book passes muster and is worth reviewing, then the following points should be part of a reviewer’s thinking:

  1. The writer has expended a lot of time and energy on his work. Respect that and offer positive feedback where possible. 
  2. The writer will have written this book with a specific intention. Figure out what that is and assess the extent to which he has achieved his purpose 
  3. To achieve his aims, the writer will have set his book in a specific milieu. Don’t complain about this milieu, arguing that you don’t like it. Review what’s there, and it’s relationship to the author’s purpose. You own preferences are irrelevant.
  4. The writer will have established a set of values for his characters. If you find these diametrically opposed to your own values, don’t sneer or mock them. You must put your own predilections on hold and review what’s there. You can question their relevance, but if they are part of the fabric of the story, do not criticise or belittle them. 
  5. Then, of course, there are the standard areas that might find mention in a good review – the quality of the writing, characterisation, complexity of plot, structure, story-telling ability, originality, coherence. All of these areas do merit examination by a reviewer and, should there are genuine weaknesses here, then, by all means, they should be pointed out.

These few thoughts were prompted by a comment in a review of my latest book, an occult mystery thriller entitled, The Coven Murders (https://tinyurl.com/ybkx8bkh».). The reviewer said:

“.... was not exactly the right book for me. It is a much better book for someone who is more religiously inclined ... While I do feel like the elements, its rituals and beliefs, felt real enough, I had trouble taking them seriously. There were several times during the book, with earnest dialogue between characters, that I found myself giggling and scolding myself with a firm "Yep, yep, you're definitely going to Hell." (The bold lines are the reviewer’s)

This is a perfect example of the kind of comment reviewers should avoid. It is clearly snide, panders to the reviewer’s own ego, and attempts to impose values that are irrelevant to those of the story. It offers nothing constructive for the author to consider and, indeed, seeks to present the story in a very poor light. Again I wonder, who do such comments serve, and why should any reviewer feel that they are necessary?

2 years ago
professor 2 years ago

Closed due to inactivity.

Back to Mystery Suspense...

Back to ASMSG Forums

You must be logged in to post in this forum. You are logged in as .


Aken,Stuart @stuartaken stuartaken.blogspot.com
Allan, Shaun @singularityspnt singularityspoint.blogspot.com
Amoateng, James @AmoatengJames1
Barnes,Ruby @Ruby_Barnes http://rubybarnes.blogspot.com
Benchley, Victoria @vbenchley http://victoriabenchley.com/
Bishop, Ally @upgradestory allybishop.com
Brumfield,Jami @JamiMBrumfield
Bryn, Rebecca @RebeccaBryn1 .rebeccabrynandsarahstuart-novels.co.uk
Bryson,Tom @TomBryson2
Burke,Anna Celeste @aburke59 http://www.desertcitiesmystery.com/
Burke, Suzanna @pursoot https://sooozburkeauthor.wordpress.com/
Burns, Tamy @WhatSheKnewBook krhughestlburns.wordpress.com
Cameron,J.B. http://jbcameron.blogspot.ca
Campbell, Chester D. @ChesterCampbell http://chestercampbell.blogspot.com
Chapman, John @JChapman1729 http://authorbookpromotion.blogspot.co.uk/
Carey, Lorrainne @StorySpirit4U http://adele-angelic-lights.blogspot.com/
Clark,Norm @Norm_Clark www.normclarkauthor.weebly.com
Cliff, Jim @IndieAuthorUK
Cozzone,Kelly @KCozzone http://www.therelationshipscafe.com/
Dawson,Honor_Amelia @HonADawson http://honoradawson.wordpress.com
Devonshire,Sabrina @SabrinaDevonsh1 www.sabrinadevonshireromances.com
Dewey,Genevieve @GenevieveDewey GenevieveDewey.com
deWolfe,Adrienne @AdriennedeWolfe http://writingnovelsthatsell.com/blog/
Dizon,John_Reinhard @JohnRDizon
Dolan,John @JohnDolanAuthor http://johndolanwriter.blogspot.com/
Dougherty,Victoria @vicdougherty http://victoriadougherty.wordpress.com/
Drewa, Viv @vivdrewa https://theowlladyblog.wordpress.com/
Finlay, Barry @Karver2
Foley, Sahara @SaharaFoley http://sharafoley.blogspot.com/
Gates,Eric J. @eThrillerWriter http://my-thrillers.blogspot.com.es/
Harman,Dianne @diannedharman dianneharman.com
Hawkinson, Wodke @WodkeHawkinson
Hutson,Ian @dieselelephants
Jahn,Amalie @AmalieJahn http://www.theclaylion.com/blog.html
Javed,Xunaira @XunairaJ http://xunairaj.com/
Kappes,Tonya @tonyakappes11
Kincaid, Juliet @JulietKincaid http://julietkincaid.com
King,Samara @samaraking http://charactersbehavingbadly.com
Kirby, Seb @Seb_Kirby
Lavanway, Ilyan Kei @ilyanlavanway http://ebooksscifi.wordpress.com/
Lavy,Sharon_A. @OldOrderTweeter
Lawlor,David @LawlorDavid http://historywithatwist.wordpress.com/
Lerma, Felipe Adan @FelipeAdanLerma https://felipeadanlerma.com/
Little,C.H. @Chlittleauthor http://www.chlittle.com/blog/
London,Ceri @CeriLondon http://cerilondon.wordpress.com/
Mahon,Alex @wearywanderer64 http://alexanderthomasmahon.wordpress.com/
Marvell,Carol @carolmarvell billiemccoy.blogspot.com.au/
Mattana,Stefania @EraniaPinnera http://dailypinner.eraniapinnera.com/
McCaw, Janine @mc_janine http://www.supernaturalcentral.blogspot.ca/
McClendon,Lise @LiseMcClendon http://lisemcclendon.com/blog/
McCoy, VR @VRMcCoy
McDaniels,Edison @surgeonwriter http://surgeonwriter.com/blog
Meehan,Scott @MeehanAScott http://scottameehan.wordpress.com/
Metz,Amy @authoramymetz http://abluemillionbooks.blogspot.com/
Montgomery,Thomas_E @ThomasEMont http://sylvaniajackson.com
Mortimer,Faith @FaithMortimer http://www.faithmortimerauthor.com/
Muhammad,Khalid @AgencyRulesPK
Mullis,Clive @CliveMullis http://clivemullis.blogspot.co.uk/
Parke,Iain @IainParke www.bad-press.co.uk
Pireel,Lucy @LucyPireel http://lucypireel.wordpress.com/
Pireel,Lucy @LucyPireel http://lucypireel.wordpress.com/
Ramirez,Steven @byStevenRamirez stevenramirez.com
Raynes, H. A. @hollyiswriting
Rector,Bob @RectorWriter
Right,Emma @emmbeliever emmaright.com/blog-life-homeschooling-parenting-writing-christian-insights
Roberts,Lilian @lilian3roberts
Ryan,Vanessa_A. @vryan333 vanessaryanwriter.blogspot.com/
Sartor, Nancy @Nancy37076 horrorsandhurrahs.wordpress.com/
Schwartz,Jinx @jinxschwartz
Seeley,Annalynne @ad_seeley http://www.adseeley.com/Blog.aspx
Silkstone,Barbara @barbsilkstone http://barbswire-ebooksandmore.blogspot.com
Stibbe, Claire @CMTStibbe https://clairestibbe.wordpress.com/
Stone,Ash @newage_author http://www.fit4amom.blogspot.com
Swan,Maria-Grazia @scrittrice mariagraziaswan.com/stories-my-grandfather-told-me-and-other-tall-tales/
Tardif,Cheryl-Kaye @cherylktardif http://www.cherylktardif.blogspot.com
Taylor,Laura @AuthorLTaylor
Tilbury, Mark @MTilburyAuthor http://www.marktilbury.com
Toussaint, Maggie @MaggieToussaint http://www.mudpiesandmagnolias.blogspot.com/
Tullis,Stephany @StephanyTullis
Updegrove, Andrew @Adversego https://updegrove.wordpress.com/
Vandiver,Abby_L. @AbbyVandiver
Watkins, Linda @Splatland http://lindawatkins.biz
Wester,Vanessa @vanessa_wester http://vanessawesterwriter.blogspot.co.uk/
Wilson, Muffy @SexyMuffyWilson http://muffywilson.blogspot.com
Zick,P.C. @PCZick http://pczick.com/